Edit this page
Modify this page
Edit this string
You are here: Home >News & Events >Articles >
CLOSE CALL: European Union finally rejects horrific mass surveillance legislation

The British government’s mass surveillance powers have been severely undermined by the European Union’s top court. The new ruling could constrain police and spy agency investigations. The judgement was handed down in December 2016, in Luxembourg, where the European Court of Justice declared that general and indiscriminate data retention regarding people’s communications and whereabouts is inconsistent with privacy rights. The court stated that bulk storage of private data is highly invasive and exceeds the limits of necessity, therefore it can’t be justified within a democratic society.

The ruling is a victory for civil liberties advocates, but a major blow against mass surveillance. Retention of our digital histories is a very intrusive form of surveillance which needs safeguarding. The 15 judges on the European court’s panel acknowledged that modern investigative techniques were necessary to fight against organized crime and terrorism efforts, but couldn’t justify general and indiscriminate retention of all traffic and location data.


It is still acceptable, however, for governments to perform targeted data retention. This pertains to cases involving serious crimes, but access to that data must be overseen by a judicial authority or independent administrative authority. Those who were targeted by surveillance will be notified upon completion of the investigation.

In December, 2014, two British members of parliament originated the case by challenging the legality of the UK government’s Data Retention, where telecommunications companies were forced to store their customers’ communication records for one year. The law was replaced with the Investigatory Powers Act, which was approved by British Parliament.

Since the UK recently voted to leave the European Union, the significant ruling will likely be a headache for British government officials. The ruling was forwarded to the UK’s Court of Appeal, so judges could determine how it will be applied in context with the national law. This might force the government to make changes to controversial sections of the Investigatory Powers Act, which gives police and spy agencies an abundance of access to civilian data.

This will mark the UK government’s first serious post-Brexit test to their commitment for protecting human rights and the rule of law. The people of the UK have voted to leave the EU, but not to give up their rights and freedoms. The government must now make significant changes to the Investigatory Powers Act in order to comply with the people’s personal privacy rights.

In a statement from the British government’s Home Office, a spokesperson said that “We are disappointed with the judgment from the European Court of Justice and will be considering its potential implications. The Government will be putting forward robust arguments to the Court of Appeal about the strength of our existing regime for communications data retention and access.

The UK’s appeal of the decision is likely be dragged out for a long time. If the appeal can outlast the completion of the Brexit process, the ruling will no longer matter. This should raise questions concerning politicians who are granting the government powers to inappropriately spy on citizens.


February 15, 2017


Articles published recently

> 26 JulyPutin On Uni-Polarity’s Failure

> 24 JulyRussia claims it can wipe out the entire US Navy with an advanced electronic warfare weapon…

> 23 JulyRussian Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov: John McCain is schizophrenic

> 23 JulyBaby Twins Die Simultaneously After Routine Vaccinations

> 21 JulyAfter pushing LGBT agenda for children, Disney files patent on cuddly robots that could be used as «sex toys» for children

> 21 JulyGOD'S GPS

> 20 JulyCoca-Cola responsible for polluting the Earth with 100 billion plastic bottles, reveals alarming investigation

> 19 JulyWhat will US do in post-ISIS era?

> 18 JulyBombs in the Air – Then Boots on the Ground

> 18 JulyHungary PM: «George Soros Has Ruined the Lives of Millions of Europeans»

> 17 JulyGovernment by Psychotronics?

> 17 JulyDeep State Neuroscientists Believe They Can Turn Off Free Will

> 16 JulyMore and more men nowadays are put in front of a difficult choice – mobile phone, or virility?

> 15 JulyGermany Has Created an Artificial Sun To Make Clean Energy

> 14 JulyEleven things you need to let go of to be happy

> 14 JulyNASA Found That Everything The Bible Says Is True

> 14 JulyStudy: manipulating the brain to create honest behavior

> 14 JulyMainstream Science Finally Admits Vitamin C’s Ability to Cure Cancer is Not a Conspiracy Theory

> 13 JulySyria: Cui Bono?

> 13 JulyMounting tensions between NATO and Russia. Putin Prepared For World War III As Russia Evacuated 40 Million People