Italy threatens jail time for parents raising vegan children; but toxic vaccines and cancer-causing junk food are still legal
Italian parents who force a vegan or vegetarian diet on to their children under 16 could face up to seven years in jail if the Italian parliament passes the new controversial bill. The proposal comes from Elvira Savino, from the conservative Forza Italia party, who claims that these restrictive diets jeopardize the health of young children and leave them malnourished.
According to Savino and some health experts, a vegetarian or vegan diet may lack sufficient amounts of zinc, iron, vitamin D, vitamin B12, omega-3, and protein which are all essential nutrients for growth and overall health.
She told Reuters that she doesnʼt have a problem with vegans or veganism, as long as it is a free choice that is being made by adults. However, she did go on to say “I just find it absurd that parents are allowed to impose their will on children in an almost fanatical, religious way, often without proper scientific knowledge or medical advice.”
Vegetarian and vegan diets suitable for children or not?
According to the American Dietetic Association, a well-planned vegetarian or vegan diet can be healthy, provide adequate nutrient intake, and can offer many benefits in the prevention and treatment of certain diseases, for adults and children alike.
When it comes to children, however, they said extra attention is needed to make sure they get all the nutrients they need for their mental and physical development.
Unfortunately, not all parents that make the decision to feed their little one a strict plant-based diet have done their homework. In 2015 and 2016, several Italian children have had to undergo hospitalizations, due to the effects of nutritionally insufficient, poorly planned vegan diets.
In July 2016, a little boy raised on a strict vegan diet was removed from the custody of his parents after doctors concluded that the one-year-old had the body weight of a three-month-old baby. According to the Independent, the boy showed severe calcium deficiencies and needed emergency surgery because of a heart condition. Although the vegan diet did not cause the heart disease, doctors believe it made things worse.
In 2015, a divorced Italian mother of a 12-year-old boy lost her guardianship after the father filed a complaint that the boyʼs diet was stunting his growth and harming his health.
In the light of these events, Savino is now pushing hard to penalize “reckless and dangerous eating behavior imposed by parents to the detriment of minors” according to BBC.
Savino told Reuters that she feels responsible for all children that may end up in hospital because of this behavior. She said that it is her task to protect children and pediatricians should be obliged to report vegan parents to authorities just as they would report physical abuse on a child.
If her bill is successful, imposing a vegan or vegetarian diet on a child under 16 would become a criminal offense in Italy. Offenders will face a jail sentence of a year for raising a child on such a diet, up to four years if the child suffers illness or permanent injury, and up to six or seven years if the child dies as a result.
As reported by BBC, opinions about the validity of the bill are divided. According to some experts, punitive measures are not the answer. After all, arenʼt parents of junk-food-fed obese or vaccinated children also jeopardizing the health of their child?
Should they then be imprisoned too or would it be more efficient to provide better public health education on how to improve nutrition and raise a healthy vegan kid?
January 23, 2017